• Gupta fallout

    KPMG is still losing staff and clients due to Gupta fallout, according to insiders.

  • Stimulus reaction

    Ratings agency Fitch says SA's stimulus plan is unlikely to boost growth significantly.

  • The Ramaphosa Plan

    The president said on Friday that the work "starts now". He wasn't wrong, writes Pieter du Toit.


ConCourt dismisses bicycles cartel leave to appeal

May 11 2017 18:42

Cape Town - The Constitutional Court has dismissed with costs an application for leave to appeal by two members of the bicycle cartel who were found guilty of price fixing, the Competition Commission announced on Thursday.

The case related to Omnico and Coolheat about a ruling that if a firm participates in a collusive meeting, without publicly distancing itself from what was discussed, the company has given other participants in the meeting reason to believe that it agreed to and would comply with what was decided at the meeting.

'The Constitutional Court dismissed the application for leave to appeal. This means that the precedent setting decision by the Competition Appeal Court, relating to silent or passive participation in a collusive meeting, stands," said the Commission.

In 2008 some 20 bicycle retailers and wholesalers contravened the Competition Act by agreeing to fix prices during a meeting held in September of that year. The Commission initiated a complaint against all 20 parties. The Commission subsequently concluded settlement agreements with 11 bicycle retailers and 6 wholesalers. Among others, the retailers and wholesalers admitted to having contravened the Act.

However, Omnico and Coolheat did not conclude any settlement with the Commission and pleaded not guilty. They argued at the Tribunal that they did not ‘actively participate’ in the discussions and were therefore not liable.

The Tribunal, however, found the wholesalers did nothing to distance themselves from the discussions and that their silence amounted to an agreement. Administrative penalties (fines) of R4.6m and R4.2m were imposed on Omnico and Coolheat respectively.

The two subsequently took the decision on appeal to the Competition Appeal Court. The appeal was dismissed and the CAC found that Omnico and Coolheat engaged in price fixing.

Read Fin24's top stories trending on Twitter:

Follow Fin24 on Twitter, Facebook, Google+ and Pinterest. 24.com encourages commentary submitted via MyNews24. Contributions of 200 words or more will be considered for publication.

competition commission


Company Snapshot

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

What do you think of President Cyril Ramaphosa's economic stimulus plan?

Previous results · Suggest a vote