At R175bn, govt's cumulative irregular spend now tops its annual budget for police and defence | Fin24
  • Covid-19 Money Hub

    The hub will help answer your business and money questions during the coronavirus crisis.

  • Cigarettes

    The tobacco ban is a 'deal with the devil' that undermines transformation, say lobby groups.

  • Easing the Lockdown

    Liquor makers want bars to become drink-collection points when the alcohol ban lifts.


At R175bn, govt's cumulative irregular spend now tops its annual budget for police and defence

Oct 23 2019 14:47
Lameez Omarjee

Kimi Makwetu, ouditeur-generaal van Suid-Afrika, wat diep bekommerd oor Vrystaatse munisipaliteite en die Mangaung-metro is. Foto: News24 (Foto: News 24)

Related Articles

Prasa financials too disorganised to audit - AG

Audit reports read like an SOS from SOEs, Parliament hears

Treasury entities' irregular spend reaches R1bn


The cumulative irregular expenditure incurred by government departments and public entities - up to and including the current financial year - now stands at R174.88bn.

The "closing balance" figure at the end of the 2017/18 financial year was R139.81bn, and was R115.51bn in 2016/17.  

This is according to the Auditor-General of South Africa's report on the audit outcomes of national and provincial government for 2018/19. The AG did not say which years are included in the calculation for the cumulative irregular expenditure figure. 

The findings show that for the year 2018/19 year alone, reported irregular expenditure was R61.35bn.

Auditor General Kimi Makwetu presented the findings before Parliament's Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa) on Wednesday. For perspective, government's entire annual budget for policing and the defence force, together, is R154bn. 

The AG in 2018/19 audited a total of 432 government departments and public entities. Just 23% received clean audits, while 11% still had outstanding audits as of September 2, 2019.

The majority of outstanding audits came from public entities, seven of which are state-owned enterprises. The remainder of the outstanding audits are from government departments.

Ballooning figures

Irregular expenditure for 2018/19 increased from the previous year's R50.97bn to R61.35bn. However, this figure may be understated, as not all irregular expenditure had been disclosed for the year, given that some audits are outstanding.

Notably, the number of auditees incurring irregular expenditure slightly decreased from 296 to 289, according to the AG's presentation to the committee.

The irregular expenditure mainly relates to non-compliance with supply chain management processes - a trend already observed in previous years, as well as payments made without following due process, Makwetu said.

The AG has recommended that all irregular expenditure be investigated further to determine if it was incurred due to incompetence or "malicious" motives.

Irregular expenditure is largely concentrated in KwaZulu-Natal, which accounted for R12.42bn of the irregular expenditure in the past financial year. The province is followed by national government (R11.25bn), and Gauteng (R7.13bn). 

In KwaZulu-Natal, the main culprits of irregular expenditure are its health and transport departments. Nationally, the department of water and sanitation is a driver of irregular expenditure. In Gauteng, meanwhile, the health department, as well as roads and transport, contributed the most. 

Fruitless and wasteful expenditure

Fruitless and wasteful expenditure - or expenditure which could have been avoided - decreased to R1.42bn in the 2018/19 financial year, down from the R2.57bn reported in 2017/18.

However, the AG warned that this expenditure could also be understated, as some audits are still outstanding.

Makwetu described some of this expenditure as "low-hanging fruit", including interest on late payments, litigation claim and millions related to the cancellation of accommodation, vehicles and trips. 

Unauthorised expenditure, meanwhile, or expenses which were not budgeted for, decreased from R2.13bn in 2017/18 to R1.65bn reported in 2018/19. Makwetu said this expenditure is incurred often due to a lack of planning, or a lack of rigor in keeping to the budget.

Financial health risks

The report shows that 34 auditees, excluding state-owned enterprises - were in a "vulnerable" financial position. This means they might not have the finances to continue their operations, according to the AG. About 36% auditees have a deficit which means their expenses exceed revenue.

Departments are also facing litigation claims, which are not budgeted for. This means successful claims are often paid for with funds earmarked for service delivery, the AG stated in its presentation.

As for state-owned enterprises, some like the Post Office and the Petroleum Oil and Gas Corporation of South Africa are facing going concern challenges. During the period government guarantees ballooned to R446bn, Makwetu said. SOEs are using these guarantees to secure loans.

"Guarantees or bailouts for SOEs would increase the budget deficit of the fiscus, government debt and borrowing costs, and result in downgrades from ratings agencies," the AG warned.



Company Snapshot

Voting Booth

How has Covid-19 impacted your financial position?

Previous results · Suggest a vote