Slow change blamed for unrest

2012-09-04 15:15

Johannesburg - Cyril Ramaphosa, a young black activist, was asked in 1982 to start a labour organisation for mining workers to challenge one of the most important sectors of the country's economy, then dominated by the white minority.

Ramaphosa not only founded the National Union of Mineworkers, currently one of the most powerful unions in the country, but also became the lead African National Congress (ANC) negotiator in the talks that ended Apartheid in 1994 and gave blacks the franchise.

But his negotiating skills were missing in August, when thousands of workers at the Lonmin platinum mine at Marikana went on a wildcat strike, which led to the deaths of 44 people.

Police shot 34 of them dead on August 16, in what is being seen as one of the worst instances of violence in the country since the end of Apartheid.

Ramaphosa is a board member of Lonmin, having gone full circle from fighting for workers' rights to owning key shares in a mining firm.

His story, for South Africans, is an exception to the rule that highlights the slow pace of change. While some blacks have been lifted out of poverty and have gained positions of power since 1994, deep poverty and unemployment is the more common reality.

"Too many people in South Africa are not skilled. Our education system here is in crisis.

"People are not learning the skills they need for work," says Gareth Newham, the head of the Crime and Justice Programme at the Institute of Security Studies (ISS) in Pretoria.

Unemployment hovers at around 25%, according to official figures. The government sponsored affirmative action programme - Black Economic Empowerment - has not done its job.

Though it created a small black middle class, the programme has notably enriched a small, politically connected elite, which is often accused of being corrupt.

Newham believes that because the ruling ANC is not held accountable, the country regularly finds itself dealing with urgent situations. The party is the dominant political power in the country, garnering about two-thirds of the vote in national elections.

"As long as there is no threat to the people in power in the ANC, and people are not held accountable for their ability to solve problems, then we will always be in a crisis management system," says Newham.

People in South Africa are slowly getting fed up with the pace of economic change - having gotten the vote in 1994, they now want to see a real positive impact on their day-to-day lives.

But service delivery protests are on the rise.

Last year, the number of such protests against government failings to deliver basic services like water, electricity, housing and education reached an all time high.

Some areas of the country simply offer no hope to residents.

Many of the workers at the Lonmin mine in the North-West province, originally came from the Eastern Cape, where Nelson Mandela was born.

"There are no jobs in the Eastern Cape, there is nothing," said Primrose, a woman in her fifties who sells clothes outside the Lonmin mine.

She moved to Marikana in 1995, shortly after the Apartheid-era restrictions on freedom of movement for blacks were lifted.

Analysts believe that the striking Lonmin miners were joined by hundreds of unemployed people from nearby informal settlements - or shantytowns - who turned a labour dispute into a complaint against the system: the mines, the unions and the government.

"As long as people feel excluded, problems will continue," says the ISS' Newham.

The shantytowns around the mine are often no-go areas for police, indicating a lack of trust in the authorities by the growing class of working poor in South Africa.

"The violence by workers is a rejection of inequality," says one sector analyst who spoke on condition of anonymity.

Moreover, the political leaders who should have stepped up and help resolve disputes before violence erupted have largely shirked their responsibility.

Corruption is a red thread running through the debates about where the country is heading. Many top officials in the police, for example, have been fired for graft and other charges, including the past two police chiefs.

Richard Mdluli, the former head of crime intelligence at the police, is facing allegations of fraud and murder. His unit would have been responsible for gathering inside information from the scene of the Lonmin strike.

But with crime intelligence in total disarray, observers say they are not surprised the police officers facing the angry workers had no clue how to handle the situation, contributing to the brute use of live ammunition that left dozens dead and shocked the nation.

* Follow Fin24 on Facebook, Twitter and Google+.

  • jan.human - 2012-09-04 15:39

    "The violence by workers is a rejection of inequality," Unequal to what exactly? Please... 18 years later.....

  • mark.haupt.31 - 2012-09-04 16:07

    We're all aware of what the problems are, even of some solutions, but unfortunately we're all working, AND PAYING THE TAXES, so that leaves the ANC, their "black diamonds" and the unemployed to solve the problem. Kind of ironic, isn't it, that the ANC came to power on the backs of the unemployed, disadvantaged and dissatisfied and have since then blamed everything on everybody else but are still unable to solve anything? Yup, I kinda like that.

  • psalm.proverb.3 - 2012-09-04 17:00

    I will repeat what I've written elsewhere. If these "poverty striken masses" vote for the ANC in the next elections, then I must accept that they enjoy suffering. How idiotic are some of these voters? They vote in the ANC on Tuesday and next Monday they are protesting against the ANC they voted in! Actually, this is more than idiocy - it is insanity. Doing the same thing over and over again, while expecting a different result.

      koos.meyer.52 - 2012-09-04 19:32

      ANC voters are brain-dead sheep I am afraid... same with Angola. Same party in power for 33 years!!

  • CDerrenberg - 2012-09-04 21:37

    JSE significant drop to continue, ongoing, from this point, especially in the financial sector (& resources, unfortunately). Biggest impact to be seen in Firstrand (FSR), currently totally over bought / over weight, and working it's way side ways & downward as it simply cannot break current resistance levels. FSR will reach levels of 26.00 and then lower within the next week or two, which is good for investors "selling short" on this stock. Further more, and very important, another totally over bought and top heave (very over inflated) share is Old Mutual, which were just down graded in the BIG Suisse Old Mutual down grade for "negative performing companies" ! In summary, basically, this is as a result of Old Mutual having serious cash flow problems (cannot pay back share holders if they had to) as well as very limited future growth prospects, opposite to what Old Mutual has been published for the last 6 to 9 months! Fiction you may ask ?? Surely ! Just another example of a share which topped a week or so ago, and will fall from current levels within the next week to two, or less. Excellent for "short sellers" naturally ! Read more about the BIG Old Mutual down grade in Business day, page 2, yesterday, and Bloomberg, today ! Watch out and rather close positions in the above two shares positions or sell short asap ! Best Regards

  • pages:
  • 1