PIC wins court bid to have two former VBS directors declared delinquent | Fin24
  • New Notes

    Long queues have formed in Harare after Zimbabwe released new bank notes and coins.

  • Open Book

    Former President Jacob Zuma says the public protector can access his tax records.

  • Electricity

    Sowetans should pay rate of R150/month to foster a payment culture, says an ANC councillor.


PIC wins court bid to have two former VBS directors declared delinquent

Aug 26 2019 12:31
Lameez Omarjee

State asset manager the Public Investment Corporation has welcomed a high court decision to have two former executives implicated in the VBS Mutual Bank collapse declared delinquent directors.

The Pretoria High Court last week declared Ernest Nesane and Paul Magula delinquent directors. Being declared delinquent means they are disqualified from serving as company directors, according to the 2008 Companies Act. 

Nesane was the PIC's former executive head for legal counsel, governance and compliance. Magula was the corporation's former executive head for risk management.

The PIC manages about R2.2trn in investments on behalf of public servants.

The corporation dismissed Magula in April 2018 - a month after VBS was placed under curatorship - following a disciplinary process. Nesane, meanwhile, resigned in July 2018 two days after he testified before Advocate Terry Motau, SC, who was investigating the VBS collapse on behalf of the South African Reserve Bank. Motua submitted his report to the central bank in October 2018. 

"The PIC Board believes that the order to declare both Nesane and Magula delinquent is an important message to all directors to take their fiduciary responsibilities seriously and emphasises the point that unethical behaviour on the part of leadership should not be without consequences," the PIC said in a statement on Monday. 

"The decision comes at a time when the interim Board is hard at work to restore confidence and accountability at PIC."

In March 2019, both Nesane and Magula were disbarred by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority, following the PIC's application.

Delinquent directors

According to the Companies Act, a court can declare someone a delinquent director if it finds the person

  • grossly abused their position;
  • took personal advantage of information or any opportunity;
  • intentionally or by gross negligence inflicted harm upon the company; or
  • acted in a manner that amounts to gross negligence or willful misconduct in relation to the performance of the director's functions.

The order may be unconditional and last for a person's lifetime or may be subject to conditions the court considers appropriate. The Pretoria High Court order does not list any conditions. 

If found to be a delinquent director, a person can apply to the court to suspend the order of delinquency and substitute it with an order of probation. They can apply to have the order of delinquency set aside.



Company Snapshot

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

What do you think about private healthcare in SA?

Previous results · Suggest a vote