Banks fall to new low on Nene axe shock | Fin24
  • Tripartite Alliance

    Cosatu wants Finance Minister Tito Mboweni to take his own advice and retire.

  • Good Reads

    Why nonfiction books are dominating South Africa's bestseller lists.

  • Fin24’s newsletter

    Sign up to receive Fin24's top news in your inbox every morning.


Banks fall to new low on Nene axe shock

Dec 10 2015 16:14
Renee Bonorchis and Janice Kew

Johannesburg - The six-member banking index plummeted by the most since the 2008 global financial crisis after President Jacob Zuma fired Finance Minister Nhlanhla Nene.

The industry benchmark fell as much as 8.2% and was 6.7% weaker as of 11:53 in Johannesburg. FirstRand [JSE:FSR], tumbled as much as 10%, while Standard Bank Group [JSE:SBK], the biggest by assets, fell 9.1%. Barclays’s South African [JSE:BGA] unit dropped 9.2% and Nedbank [JSE:NED] retreated 8.4%.

“All the banks are built on confidence - removing the finance minister isn’t good for the country’s confidence,” said Patrice Rassou, head of equities at Sanlam Investment Management in Cape Town, which oversees about $30bn in assets.

Zuma late on Wednesday removed Nene from his post after 19 months, without giving any reasons except to say that he would be switched to another key role. His replacement is David van Rooyen, a lawmaker who is little known to locals or investors. The rand dropped as much as 5.4 percent against the dollar after Zuma’s announcement, the biggest decline since September 2011, hitting a record low of 15.3857.

READ: Zuma removes Nene as finance minister

The shock move came less than a week after credit rating companies pushed the nation closer to junk status, citing concerns over a sluggish economy and rising debt as inflation and interest rates climb. Mining and manufacturing are already under strain because of plunging metal prices and power constraints.

“A debt downgrade would also lead to increasing funding costs which is not good for banks, corporate South Africa and the man on the street who is already over indebted,” Sanlam’s Rassou said.

Other financial services companies also felt the impact, with Johannesburg’s benchmark life assurance index down 5.2%. Sanlam [JSE:SLM] plunged 8.4%, the biggest drop since October 2008. Old Mutual [JSE:OML], which relies on South Africa for more than half its profit, slid as much as 3.6%, the most in more than a month.

Impairment worries

Investors may be concerned that the risk of increased impairments for bad debt is increasing, said David Shapiro, a director at Johannesburg-based money manager Sasfin Securities.

“Are the banks lending to an economy that perhaps can’t handle it?” he said by phone. “You’d expect rising debt levels as inflation surges.”

READ: Nene axing may lead to January rate hikes

The sell-off in banks could be a sign that foreign investors are pulling funds out of the South African market, Shapiro said. “They are being used as punching bags,” he said. “The banks are the ones lending to the manufacturers and miners.”

Investec [JSE:INL] fell as much as 3.7%, while Capitec Bank [JSE:CPI], which provides unsecured loans, dropped as much as 7.3%.

Rene van Wyk, the head of bank regulation in South Africa at the central bank, declined to speak about the plunge in the lenders’ stocks when called at his office in the capital, Pretoria. He referred questions to the central bank’s media department.

‘Never know’

“Investors are now more worried about a downgrade to junk status,” Wayne McCurrie, who helps manage R170bn at MMI Group, said by phone.

“In South Africa, you just never know what’s coming. This increases uncertainty and the new finance minister is mostly unknown.

“The banks are the cheap part of the market,” he said. “It just shows that being cheap doesn’t help when sentiment turns.”



Company Snapshot

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

Do you think government can solve the Eskom crisis?

Previous results · Suggest a vote