Shuttleworth charge was not a tax, court hears | Fin24

Shuttleworth charge was not a tax, court hears

Mar 04 2015 06:14

Johannesburg - The exchange control charge imposed on Mark Shuttleworth formed part of a regulatory environment and was not a tax, the Constitutional Court heard on Tuesday.

Jeremy Gauntlett SC, for the SA Reserve Bank (Sarb), told the court: "The question is, is it a tax for the purpose of the Constitution or is it a charge that forms part of a regulatory environment?

"Our learned friends [Shuttleworth's counsel] say the former, we say the latter."

Were it a tax, it would have required an appropriation from parliament.

Gauntlett said capital outflows were "scary", as shown for example in 1933 during the Great Depression, where the flight of people and capital posed a serious problem for governments, especially if they happened quickly.

The imposition of the charge served to slow down the movement of capital, not people, Gauntlett said.

Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke asked Gauntlett: "On your argument you pay to exit, and you pay only if you choose to exit?

"On your argument it is not a tax... but seeks revenue across the length and breadth of this land?"

Gauntlett replied that the critical thing was that the main purpose of the controls was to discourage the transfer of capital.

"The dominant purpose is to regulatory control conduct," he said.

Last year, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ordered that the Sarb repay Shuttleworth R250m plus interest in a case about exchange controls.

The matter dates back to March 5, 2008, when Shuttleworth applied to the Sarb to transfer R1.5bn out of South Africa when he moved to the Isle of Man.

sarb  |  mark shuttleworth  |  foreign exchange


Read Fin24’s Comments Policy publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
1 comment
Comments have been closed for this article.

Company Snapshot

Voting Booth

How concerned are you about ransomware attacks?

Previous results · Suggest a vote