'Blackout towns' named

A leaked document shows that a number of municipalities are not paying their Eskom accounts and may end up without electricity.

Old Gs never die

Leave the grandstanding to the G20 - the G7 is where the real talking gets done, says CNN International Correspondent Richard Quest.
Where am I? Fin24.com  > Economy

Eskom criticism 'xenophobic'

May 14 2008 16:13

Cape Town - Demands from various quarters that South Africa stop its electricity exports to neighbouring countries amounted to "economic xenophobia", Public Enterprises Minister Alec Erwin said on Wednesday.

"We treat our customers in neighbouring countries as customers; they actually don't have everything our South African customers have, but we've got to continue to treat them as customers," he told a media briefing at parliament.

It was an integrated system, with SA importing power from its neighbours -- and would continue to do so in future -- and selling power to them now.

"So for the life of me, I still cannot comprehend this logic that somehow we must punish these foreign customers, and that we're somehow criminal in exporting to them.

"For me it's unfathomable that we even contemplate that proposition, and we should stop doing it, because you can see sometimes the dangerous implications it has," he said.

It was a mindless approach.

"You have these absolutely unacceptable, disastrous and barbaric activities taking place [as in Alexandra], and here we are as senior informed leaders, and we also sort of convey some kind of economic xenophobia. Now we must stop it. It's nonsense," Erwin said.

Eskom's customers outside SA would be treated exactly like any other customer with the same rights, and this would remain so.

The amount SA exported was not large enough to be of major significance for its system in any event.

"But let me tell you, that there'll be a time when we import from our neighbours in amounts that will be very significant.

"Now, if I was in the Congo or Mozambique and some South African government, just when it had a crisis, chopped me off without any regard for the effect on me, I would make very certain that in future I'd do something similar to them.

"We've got to carry on treating people fairly," Erwin said.

- Sapa

 

Add your comment

(No bad language or hate speech, please)

Comments Order    

Bryan
Jun 03 2008 18:15 Report this comment

xenophobic is just another word for BEEE in south africa. are whites not citizens of this country as well, I would like to ask mebeki one question. is he on cocain.
 
Terence
May 19 2008 08:21 Report this comment

Richard - 'Dick' Craneum - 'Head. Xenophobic does not stem from not giving your car to someone else so that you end up having to walk to work. Where on earth do you get your logic from Erwin. Please retire, senility has attacked whatever braincells you may have once had!!
 
Fubar
May 16 2008 22:20 Report this comment

Fair enough in regards to the argument. BUT what should happen is that their cost for electricity should be the same as that of the SA public! It is NOT fair to discount our electricity AND then expect us to accept a 50% increase in price to cover the butts of crappy planning done by government and Eksdom that got us here in the first place! Do your damn jobs and we would not have this problem so start with!
 
AJC
May 16 2008 07:22 Report this comment

Mr Erwin, if a South African domestic or industrial customer does not pay his electricity, they are cut off promptly. But if another country doesn’t pay, their highly discounted bill, the normal tariff and discount is promptly footed by the South African taxpayer. That is definitely not the meaning of xenophobic, try checking words in the dictionary before you spew any more garbage to the people who pay you an inflated gravy train salary.
 
sparky
May 15 2008 14:15 Report this comment

If ESKOM was a private company, it could sell electricity to whomever it pleases. It is not. Their mandate is to supply power to SA, not the neighbouring countries. All this talk of "customer obligations" and "treating all customers equally" is absolute rubbish. ESKOM should only be selling surplus power to foreign countries, and at the moment there is by their own admission no surplus power. Alec Erwin is clown, but not a very funny one. His references to xenophobia are as laughable as the earlier government statements that the power crisis is actually a blessing due to the fact that it occurred because of our rapid economic growth. I wonder who the complete morons are that come up with these spins ?
 
Anoy
May 15 2008 13:56 Report this comment

When i listened to Mr Erwin's rediculous comments last night on the news - i was completely astounded - could he hear himself? - did he think what he said through? Cause for the life of me, I can't imagine a more stupid thing to say to the people that are paying for Eskom's mistakes. The man is a joke.
 
gpwengineer
May 15 2008 13:30 Report this comment

Alec almost sounds as bad as Mbeki's infamous "What crisis?" comment. Maybe cutting the supply to neighbouring countries would be a bit unneighbourly, but then, why not let the neighbours contribute to rising cost of generating electricity. That seems fair. Zimbabwe could pay us their whole GDP for a month's worth of electricity.Botswana and Namibia could surely afford a 53% energy hike. The point is that like any other country, the needs of the taxpayers come first.As it looks now, if you going to cut the throats of the SA taxpayer with the intended hike,who is going to pay for the electricity then? I think Alec has always been one for excuses and no solutions.I think the public's opinion to cut supply to the neighbouring states is not malicious, but rather a indication that Alec has not been able to come up with a acceptable alternative.
 
MK
May 15 2008 13:17 Report this comment

Dear Smart Alec You seem to miss the point that the electorate is rather peeved, and justifiably so, that your department and that of minerals and energy affairs have stuffed up so badly. No amount of pontificating and bad mouthing us will change or divert attention away from that fact - ever. When government refused to heed the calls for extra generating infrastructure in light of increasing domestic requirements did you stop to think .....oops maybe we shouldn't renegotiate export deals in the light (pun intended) of our own supply problems. But noooo "lets go hell for leather if all else fails we can always bad mouth those we are meant to serve and have dismally failed". Don't have much respect for you sir - but I suppose you'll carry on regardless anyway.
 
 
Your name  
Email  
Comment
(500 characters remaining)
 

 
Please enter the text below(Case sensitive)
 
 
If you can see the following field, please ignore it, as it is used to verify that you are human.

 
  Disclaimer

Fin24.com encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of users published on Fin24.com are therefore their own and do not represent the views of Fin24.com. All posts are monitored by Fin24.com's editors and grossly derogatory posts will be deleted. The Fin24.com editorial team will delete your comment should you post abusive comments, use vulgar language or make discriminatory observations.

Company Snapshot

Video

5 questions with John Munro
2010/02/08 05:25:00 PM

Fin24.com spoke to the Rand Uranium CEO at the 2010 Mining Indaba about the company's planned R3.5bn plant. Time: 2:08

Search engine friendly content

Blogs

Podcasts