Entrepreneurship Q&A

Do you have questions on the financing needs of your business? Fin24.com has a panel of experts on standby to answer queries.

PODCAST: Lessons from Abroad

Think it's easier to start a business in the US as opposed to SA? Listen to Fin24.com's entrepreneurship experts.
Where am I? Fin24.com

Foreign soccer players to pay SA tax

May 17 2010 22:28 Ruan Jooste Print this article  |  Email article

Related Articles

Cost of Bafana shirts 'ridiculous'

Zuma admits more jobs may be lost

Tourism looks for long-term gains

Lower earners must register for tax

Fines helped boost tax take

Tax take beats forecasts by R8bn

 

Johannesburg - One local instititution set to win from the country’s hosting of the 2010 Fifa World Cup is the South African Revenue Service (Sars).

While Sars has granted certain tax concessions on the supply of goods and services relevant to hosting the tournament, foreign soccer players will not be exempt from tax, and measures have been put in place to ensure their taxes are collected.  

As a norm, South Africa taxes non-residents on a source basis – meaning that receipts from sources within the borders of the country are subject to tax. Applying the source basis, earnings received by foreign sportspersons from activities they perform in SA are thus subject to tax.

Sars has recognised the challenge of collecting the tax on these earnings, given the short period players will be present in SA, as foreign rugby and cricket players have escaped paying any form of tax on earnings for their performances during previously staged rugby and cricket world cups.

But practical tax collecting problems have now been rectified and Di Seccombe of audit, tax and advisory firm Mazars said Sars will be collecting in 2010. 

Tax legislation now places the obligation on the South African resident paying foreign sportsmen undertaking a so-called specified activity to withhold tax at a rate of 15%. "A 'specified activity' is defined in the Income Tax Act as any personal activity undertaken by the foreign sportsperson in South Africa, whether alone or with other people," said Seccombe.  

"Any South African resident failing to withhold the correct amount of tax and pay it over to Sars within 30 days will find themselves personally liable for the taxes owing. Theoretically, the SA resident will then need to recover the taxes paid from the foreign sportsperson."

- Fin24.com

  • page

 

Comment on this story

(No bad language or hate speech, please)
All comments are moderated before displaying on the site
Pierre edge Jun 09 2010 17:21
GINA, you mus be blonde right? Their currency might be their 12x, 10x 8x and 5x our rand, but the prices of goods here are also 10x higher in SA, example, an lcd TV here cost 5000 average, it cost 500 euros average A citroen C1 costs 7500 euros, and over 100 000 here... And if the euro is over-rated, then what about the rand then, doesnt make any sense at 7/1 to the US. Frankly stop talking about the economy, too complex for you. Suggest you go to zim for your holidays, you;ll enjoy it. Tax101, fifa pays 6.6M euros per team to their asociation, so no need to complicate matters. End of the day, best way to kill pleasure is to tax it next, they dont milk tourist in europe, the prices are the SAME for all (Locals and tourist), they dont wait after our piddly rands to survive in europe
 
@tax 101 Jun 09 2010 16:37
No the DTA won't take the sportsman out. See article 17 of the OECD model tax convention or the SA/UK and SA/France DTA's for examples. Art 17(1) and 17(2) gives both states the right to tax. The player from France may then claim a credit either in terms of unilateral tax relief (equivalent to our section 6 quat) or in the alternative Article 23 of the France /SA DTA.
 
pierre edge Jun 09 2010 16:35
Whaat??? is this a joke or what? doesn't make any sense, the english federation will pay the england players in their countries and the same for all the others. ridiculous
 
Gina @ phil May 31 2010 15:50
Come on Phil Europe is run by White Governments and they are ripping the tourists off.We travel to europe once a year and you cannot keep up with daily costs of parking, toilets and food not forgetting the hotels you have to live in for R1200.00 per day most of them do not even include breakfast, which will then cost you and extra R190.00 per person, so do not complain the rest of the world is unconcerned about your rate of exchange problems. We have notice this year that the EURO is very overated what you get for it is not worth the trouble visiting Europe. We are living in a good and beautiful country believe me.
 
Gina May 31 2010 15:37
SA is not skinning the tourists, I have just been on a European holiday and man do you pay. Parking is Euro4.04(R40.00) and hour to use public and Departmental store tolets 0.50cent(R5.00) the lest you can pay for a meal is R100.00 so stop complaining about the tourists. They come here with their 12x, 10x 8x and 5x our rand they are already in the pound seats do not feel sorry for them, they do not feel sorry for you anywhere in europe. Within seconds of parking our car at hotel in Amsterdam, we had a parking fine because we could not get the parking ticket back to the car quick enough, so do not complain about South Africa, we have a jewel here.
 
Tax 101 May 20 2010 10:21
Last time I looked at tax law the following applied. Tax can be applied in 2 ways: Source or Residence & countries choose 1 or the other method. I.e. where the money come from or where you come from. SA works on source so money deriving from a source in SA is subject to tax. Foreign players are therefore liable to pay this BUT in many cases this will be waived where double taxation agreements exist between SA & the player's country to avoid taxing them twice. I would expect a player from a country which chooses the residence basis may be able to escape tax in their home country if playing offshore but would still be liable for SA tax.
 
j May 20 2010 08:28
SARS should get enough money from vat this is not pratical at all just like there plan to register everyone earning including people who don't have to pay tax
 
pRESHEN GOVENDER May 20 2010 08:01
you will never walk alone with SARS
 
Marc May 19 2010 20:21
@TonyCT. This article is not incorrect. This is the legislation of the country in the income tax act of South Africa, section 47A-47K. Moreover the fact that a resident has to withhold this tax on behalf of SARS and pay it over, is also correct as otherwise the process of collecting this tax would be almost impossible. To answer other people's queries about residents being responsible for collecting tax, is that this is no different to VAT which is in reality collected by companies on behalf of SARS.I do not understand why South African residents are complaining as the more tax collected the more money the government has to spend on improving infrastructure. Obviously this government has problems in allocating collected funds correctly but that should not be reason to be totally against this withholding tax. Moreover something which is incorrect in this article is that even though the resident becomes liable for the tax if not withheld, the person who is in fact eventually liable for the tax according to section 47C is the foreign sports person. Also by making the comment that there are only 5 million tax payers in South Africa and equate that to a 10% collection rate, is totally incorrect. First of all unemployment in this country is about 40% and generally children do not pay tax and we have a tax threshold in South Africa, which if you earn below do not have to pay tax. So our collection rate is actually excellent. Think before you make such an ignorant comment.Please do research before you make inaccurate comments!
 
Maradona May 19 2010 13:08
Argentina will win the world cup, go home and have siesta with the wifes. No body will pay you a cent. Fifa owns your country for a month. Fifa need Argentina. They run the show. This is football.
 
ed May 18 2010 17:42
I thought you pay taxes in the country where you live and work. These foreign soccer players pay taxes in their own countries...not SA. Is this article a joke?
 
Official from FIFA May 18 2010 11:23
No worries ...FIFA own all the rights and patents etc to this tournament...the soccer players are playing on FIFA's Soccer Stadiums ..not South Africa's therefore SARS has no rights etc just like the rest of the country..The Police are working for FIFA now ...be prepared to get sued SARS...LOL
 
Sge May 18 2010 11:15
What SARS is doing applies to everyone...soccer player or not...so stop being so negative all the time. A 15% withholding tax is not even close to the marginatal tax rate anyway
 
TonyCT May 18 2010 11:03
Junk article which is not factually correct. If the player is registered as a tax-payer elsewhere and provides proof thereof, he does not need to pay tax in RSA as he will be taxed on his earnings in RSA in the country where he resides.
 
Blacklogic May 18 2010 10:21
I see people like to just be negative for the sake of being negative, the same rules apply elsewhere so why is this even an issue for all of you whom it does not even affect. If the players dont want to pay they can simply boycott the world cup. @ Phil so all the spending that we did must not have a return eeer because we are in Africa, please man take your attidute some else.
 
HE May 18 2010 10:07
Yes, S A needs the money and as a previous comments mentions there is a relative small number of taxpayers in this country and every opportunity is welcome to hold the hand out and to collect. The turnup of visitors to SA will tell what they are thinking of the country. The Beauty is there but right behind the uggliness of crime, corruption etc - I would not be a visitor to the World Cup, I would rather stay safe at home and enjoy a hasslefree country without strikes, crime etc
 
Vincent May 18 2010 10:06
When does SARS ever not win is the question hehe. Gosh they going to make a killing with the Tourists that is coming?
 
mike May 18 2010 09:57
@Leendert Stolk I agree, badly written/explained article.
 
Blacklogic May 18 2010 09:50
Most of you are just agianst anything the goverment does without offering anyhing better, just like politicians during elections, the same rules apply everywhere even in the so-called 1st world countries, please dont just be against things just for the sake of it. it exposes your intelect.
 
Aki May 18 2010 09:12
@Leendert Stolk >> When non-residents are taxed on source basis that means the income earned by the foreign players by applying their skills in the world cup (in SA), from a resident or non-resident, will be subject to tax. It doesn't matter who pays the players - what is important is that they are paid for applying their skills in a tournament that takes place in SA.
 
Conserned person May 18 2010 09:01
Does this make sense to anyone? Seems very strange to me. is the responsibilty of collecting the tax becoming our/citizens duty?
 
BART May 18 2010 08:19
Dont they Always.
 
moneychanger May 18 2010 07:59
Great for tourism and great for honest taxpaying SA citizens. SARS will be so busy chasing after once off visits from soccer players that they will lay off harassing honest locals, at least for a few weeks!
 
Fandash May 18 2010 06:49
Sh.t and pay is the SA way.
 
WTF May 18 2010 05:31
With over 13 million people in this country recieving a social grant, the government is trying its utmost to get money from anything that dares to move. People rant and rave how effecient SARS is but choose to forget that out of a population of 50 million, there are only 5 million tax payers. That a collection rate of only 10% whereas in first world countries like the US and UK, the collection rate is close to 60 and 70%. Therefore SARS is no well oiled machine but a well focused one instead choosing to chase the soft targets instead of applying the tax law equally and nabbing everyone who doesnt pay tax.
 
Haibo May 18 2010 03:55
Good tax them on their annual salaries at least 2% for the time they are here as well, SA needs the money.....we must also tax all visitors to this country on arrival so that we we don't have to run after them to collect the money....we are a poor country we must get money anyway we can viva-viva the revolution aluta continua.
 
Phil May 18 2010 03:26
One would think that a recently "liberated" democratic third world African country such as South Africa would remain grateful for being awarded the great privilege of hosting such a prestigous world sporting event. Alas it appears this is not the case and the idea of "what can we take from them" attitude that is adopted, it's the old adage that is so inherently inbred in African culture.
 
Morpheus May 18 2010 03:05
Good news at last, so does this mean that each player will be contributing over a billion rand so that sars can profit from this ?
 
George May 18 2010 01:56
Wow, I bet all the foreign soccer players will be clamouring to come here after hearing that news!! I think not!!! How to win friends and influence people!!!!
 
Bryan May 18 2010 01:36
What a joke.
 
Ronaldo May 18 2010 01:07
Thats right....do us from behind while you can. You will never get the chance again.
 
Leendert Stolk May 18 2010 00:23
Is it me or does this article make no sense whatsoever?? Which SA resident is going to be paying the Brazil team to play football in SA? Aren't all players paid by their national association and NOT by a SA resident? I can only see the SA national team being taxed this way. Could do with a decent explanation.
 
Expected May 18 2010 00:04
Way to find another way to SKIN the Tourists ( even though they are soccer players,they are tomorrows HIGH spending tourists) idiots!
 
 
Your name *
Email *
Comment *
 

Please enter the text in the image below as is into the given textbox:

Captcha image
*
 
 

Disclaimer

Fin24.com encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of users published on Fin24.com are therefore their own and do not represent the views of Fin24.com. All posts are monitored by Fin24.com's editors and grossly derogatory posts will be deleted. The Fin24.com editorial team will delete your comment should you post abusive comments, use vulgar language or make discriminatory observations.

Indicators

Last updated: Fri 00:00

View data hub

Company Snapshot

Make money from art
Sep 02 2010 12:48

Art's nicer to look at than stock and bond certificates, but can it make you money? Fin24.com spoke to the experts about this alternative investment class. Time: 3:00

Compare and Buy

Compare and apply for hundreds of financial products from many suppliers.

Credit cards Medical aid Current accounts Think Money

Money Clinic

Money Clinic Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Loading...