How to invest R1m
EACH week we ask an expert to allocate a hypothetical lump
sum of R1m. Investment ideas range from the stock market and stamps, to art and
Gregg Sneddon, a financial adviser at Cape-based planning
firm The Financial Coach, shares his thoughts:
I am a huge fan of unit trust and exchange-traded funds
(ETFs) - mostly because I don't have the time (or desire) to actively manage a
share portfolio and the fees are also attractive; you can access most funds at
no initial fees these days.
I also like the fact that there is no capital gains tax
(CGT) on any shares that are bought and sold by the fund. I only pay CGT at the
So if I had R1m to invest right now, I would probably put
most of it offshore. This is not because I am pessimistic about the future of
SA or think that the rand is suddenly going to weaken, but mostly because the
offshore markets (especially the developed ones) appear to be providing far
better value than the SA and most emerging markets at the moment.
Sure, there is a lot of uncertainty (and possibly even
"blood on the streets") - but isn't this exactly the time that one
should be buying? After all, the return on an investment is a function of the
initial price paid; the lower the initial price, the greater the potential
Investing offshore can be done via one of two methods: asset
swap funds or direct offshore investment via tax clearance and exchange
control. In my opinion, tax clearance and exchange control is the preferred
option, but the SA Revenue Service (Sars) has made it so difficult to get tax
clearance certificates - despite the fact that the limit has been raised to R4m
per year - that it is easier to invest via an asset swap fund.
Assuming I could get a tax clearance certificate from Sars
in a reasonable amount of time, I would probably put about 50% of the money
into a balanced fund – something like the Ashburton Asset Management Service.
The fund never has more than 50% in shares, with the balance
in the other asset classes (excluding property). The equity exposure is done by
Ashburton and is global, with a bias towards developed markets. The asset
allocation is fairly actively managed and the funds have given compound annual
returns of around 7% in sterling. I'm happy with that from a low volatility
I think that I would invest the balance of the R1m as
• An allocation of 25% into the SIM Global Best Ideas Fund
(managed by Kokkie Kooyman, who was voted fund manager of the year in 2010 for
his Global Financial Fund – Investment Week's Fund Manager of the year).
This fund is Kokkie's best picks – globally. There is a fair
amount of exposure to developing markets, but quite a bit of that is via
companies that are listed in the West but derive substantial parts of their
earnings from the East. There is also a small-cap bias on the fund so it is
likely to be a bit more volatile – but that's to be expected when you invest in
• The other 25% I would probably put into something like the
Prudential M&G Global Recovery Fund. This is a multiple award-winning fund
with a deep-value bias; shares are selected from UK-listed companies. This is
classic Warren Buffett-type investing.
Reporting on each of these investments is good, and there is
more than enough access to information from each of their local offices.
- Previous Dream Big investment ideas:
Robin von Holdt, CEO of Top 100 SA Wines.
Charl Bezuidenhout, owner of the Worldart-gallery in Cape Town.
Schalk Louw, head of Contego Asset Management.
Alan Rogers, president of the Philatelic Federation of SA.
Check out Contrarius - Stephen Mildenhall's new UK venture since he was Allan Gray CIO. Like him, Orbis has a nice bias to Japan which seems like a good "blood on the streets" buy to me.
Good if there is no initial fee, better if we knew what the annual fee was...
This guy was my maths teacher. I'm still poor.
Invest in your home is still the best investment you can possibly make. Stocks etc are too risky and if you listen to the radio about finance houses the ones talking sponsor the program hoping to sell their products to you. I've been part of this once and the return received was minimal though must admit there was a return. If I had put that away towards my house the benefit would have been greater. I'm a huge sceptic of finance houses - nobody in this world want to make your money work for you, they do it for themselves and get super rich and you get but a portion of your investment.
Beware of investing overseas if you do not have easy control or full knowledge of the fund - I've just lost the lot that was invested 12 years ago with Royal Skandia. The brokers are there to make a living not to look after you. So sad to be 63 and lose 50% of my original net asset value.
Still think the government long bond yields are a better option