• Change of culture needed

    The right leadership will help SA shed its culture of violence, says Mandi Smallhorne.

  • 10 tips to find bargains

    Susan Erasmus gives advice on how bargain hunters can get the most bang for their buck.

  • Inside Labour

    Labour's bitter breaches need to be seen in historical context, says Terry Bell.

See More

Santam: short-term favourite

Aug 30 2009 10:02 Adri van Zyl

Related Articles

Santam poised for upswing

Santam sells Lion stake

Investments let Santam soar

M&F is new investor darling

Santam profit jumps 220%

Insurers 'close to bottom'


Johannesburg - Between the two short-term insurers Santam and Mutual & Federal (M&F), Santam is by far analysts' favourite.

Both shares are good investments, but Santam is far ahead of its competitor, to judge from underwriting results.

Paul Kahumuza, an analyst at Old Mutual Investment Group, said Santam has always delivered underwriting profits better than the industry average.

Investec Asset Management analyst Sarine Barnard said Santam's underwriting results have stood head and shoulders above those of M&F, especially over the past five years.

"Santam has never suffered an underwriting loss, not even in the previous distressed cycle for the insurance industry." In the six months to end-June Santam produced an underwriting profit of R88m, while M&F suffered an underwriting loss of R96m. "Santam has managed to make an underwriting profit, and the experience of its management team is reflected in that," an analyst explained.

On the other hand, Mutual & Federal's management team is fairly new.

Santam is proactive as far as industry issues are concerned, declared Barnard. The company has, for example, already gone through the process of evaluating its capital needs while M&F is only doing so now.

In July, when M&F announced its interim results, shareholders were disappointed when it passed its dividend for the second successive year.

Barnard however said that this was the correct decision to protect its capital in the current cycle. She believed M&F will again begin paying a dividend at the end of this year after reviewing the investigation into its capital requirements.

When the interim results were announced in July, M&F chief executive Keith Kennedy said the investigation would be complete within two months, after which M&F would formulate its dividend policy.

From a valuation viewpoint, Kahumuza considered Santam much more expensive than M&F, which is why he would prefer M&F as an investment at this stage.

Santam is currently trading at 2.3 times its book value compared with M&F, which is trading at 1.6 times its book value.

Barnard expected M&F to do considerably better in the second half of its financial year and turn the first-half loss around to break more or less even.

The risk that M&F's underwriting results will be worse than those of the industry as a whole is reflected in the share price, she pointed out.

M&F's shares are not as freely available as they should be. At the moment only 14% of its shares are freely tradable because Old Mutual owns a 75% controlling interest and empowerment shareholders 11%.

The JSE requires that at least 20% of a company's stock should be freely tradable.

According to Barnard this makes it likely that Old Mutual will again try to get hold of the whole of M&F.

A year or so ago Old Mutual decided that M&F was not a core operation, but an attempt to sell it failed. Now Old Mutual is taking a fresh look at M&F as a core investment.

"This raises the possibility that in the next three years Old Mutual will indeed make a bid to buy M&F," she believed. This is not an immediate prospect because Old Mutual first needs to resolve other problems.

Sanlam, which has a 54% stake in Santam, would also like to own the whole company. But, before that can happen, Santam's share price will have to fall very sharply.

Dr Johan van Zyl, the chief executive of Sanlam, is well known not to overpay for any asset.

- Sake24.com


Read Fin24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Company Snapshot

Brought to you by BizNews

More from BizNews

We're talking about:


Johannesburg has been selected to host the Global Entrepreneurship Congress in 2017. "[The congress] will ensure that small business development remains firmly on the national agenda and the radar screen of all stakeholders, the Small Business Development minister said.

Top 10 richest musicians of all time

Check out the gallery to find out who they are!


Luxury living

10 of the most expensive things that will leave your jaw hanging!
Seven of the most expensive children's toys ever made
5 millionaires turned murderers
The youngest billionaires in the world and how they made it

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

How do you see your boss? He/sheis:

Previous results · Suggest a vote