Register now for Fin24 Dashboard and get access to portfolios, watchlists, financial comparison tools, and a whole lot more to help you achieve your financial goals.

Data provided by McGregor BFA
All data is delayed
Loading...
Where am I? Home
 
Prices are delayed by 15min.
Join the Fin24.com conversation about JSE-listed stock by using every time you tweet.

Boardrooms too pale and male

Nov 05 2006 18:11

Related Articles

Breakthrough for female power

Top execs still mainly male

Fin services 'still favour men'

 

Top Stories

Cell C move sparks price war

May 27 2012 11:21

There's a price war raging between South Africa's cellphone networks after Cell C lowered the rates of its prepaid calls by more than 34%.

Another golf estate victim

May 27 2012 13:09

The oversupply of golf estates has claimed another victim.

MyCiti buses running at a loss

May 28 2012 07:53

The City of Cape Town has spent R175m running the Myciti bus service since the Soccer World Cup compared to an income of R35m, a report says.

 
Share Share line Print
Johannesburg - Political inequality in South Africa may be a thing of the past but the racial and gender divide appears very much intact when it comes to the boardroom, a new study shows.

The government of Thabo Mbeki, following the lead of his predecessor Nelson Mandela, has consistently pushed firms to do more to ensure that company directors reflect the make-up of a country where blacks account for around 80% of the population.

However a new book that claims to be the first comprehensive study of the nation's boardrooms since the end of apartheid in 1994 reveals that the pace of economic transformation remains painfully slow.

"It is a hell of a slow pace ... Not much of an improvement," says Renee Bonorchis, co-author of "Executive Pay In South Africa - Who Gets What And Why."

The decades before the advent of multi-racial democracy saw blacks systematically excluded from positions of power in the economy.

Since 1994, the government has been promoting a programme of Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) as a central plank of its growth strategy and says deals worth R285bn have been concluded in the last decade.

But Bonorchis said a study of 50 of some of the largest and most influential listed companies showed little had changed in the last dozen years.

'Little transformation in the boardroom'

Of a total of 697 directors, 66% are white and only 28%were black while the rest were from other ethnic minorities.

"From what we found, there is little transformation in the boardroom. Most of the executives are still white and male, earn on average R15m rand a year - more than 700 times the ground workers, who happen to be black and/or women," Bonorchis told AFP.

In a foreword to the book, Finance Minister Trevor Manuel joined the list of political and business leaders who have called for an overhaul in the boardroom to emulate the country's overall transformation.

"They (businesses) must meet the transformation challenges we have set ourselves as South Africans, working together for a non-racial and equitable future ... There is a body of literature that suggests that vastly unequal societies impede their own growth into the future," he wrote.

Mbeki has said he wants a woman to succeed him as president when he steps down in 2009, but Bonorchis and her fellow author Ann Crotty found there were "upsettingly" few female company directors.

"If you think South Africa is doing badly when it comes to empowerment of black people in the workplace, the statistics on women in the workplace is even more upsetting," they write.

"Despite President Mbeki constantly pushing for the upliftment of women, and his demonstrated commitment to this by appointing a woman as his deputy, corporate South Africa has yet to take notice.

"While most large companies would not dare to have no black directors, many of them (11 out of the 50) are quite happy to have no women on their boards."

Dramatic turnaround not expected

Bemoaning the profile of the average South African boardroom, Labour Minister Membathisi Mdladlana said in September it could take half a century before there was genuine workplace equality.

A number of black businessmen, such as Cyril Ramaphosa and Tokyo Sexwale, are household names, partly thanks to earlier political careers.

But Nick Icely, a director at the South African branch of the accountancy firm Deloitte's, said he did not expect a dramatic turnaround any time soon as it would take time for blacks and women to narrow the skills gap. "The slow pace is down to a skills shortage in the previously disadvantaged sections of the economy," he told AFP.

Azar Jammine of the Johannesburg-based consultancy Econometrix argued that BEE had so far failed to achieve its objective as the government had not addressed the skills issue.

He said it was naive to expect firms to act on their own.

"The thrust has been misplaced, with too much focus on ownership and control and too little on imparting the skills required for blacks to fulfil executive posts or to start their own business ventures," he said.

 
 
Comment on this story
0 comments
Comments have been closed for this article.
It pays to know the cost and what you’re getting in return
May 28 2012 09:33

Investors may not have a clue what they’re paying their money managers or they type of service they’re getting, or, whether they can actually negotiate lower fees. (Reuters)

Sasha

"In the short term this is true, Greece will dominate the headlines on a day to day basis, until their next elections when there would be some clarity to answer the question, "What next for Greece?" Amazingly everyone except the politicians seem to be lining themselves up for worst case scenario, b... Read their blog...

Recently updated
Podcasts
The Sishen saga

Legal expert Peter Leon on the increasingly complex legal wrangle over the Sishen Iron Ore mine. Time: 8:17 Listen Here...

Before you list

Is the clarion call of the JSE calling? Listen to Fin24’s expert panel discussion before you list your small business. Time: 17:29

Compare and Buy

Compare and apply for hundreds of financial products from many suppliers.

Credit cards Medical aid Current accounts Think Money

Money Clinic

Money Clinic Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Loading...