Entrepreneurship Q&A

Do you have questions on the financing needs of your business? Fin24.com has a panel of experts on standby to answer queries.

PODCAST: Lessons from Abroad

Think it's easier to start a business in the US as opposed to SA? Listen to Fin24.com's entrepreneurship experts.
Where am I? Fin24.com

World Bank fingers SA labour costs

Jul 29 2010 16:07 Print this article  |  Email article

Related Articles

Govt seeks foreign cash injection

VW boosts SA investment

SA foreign investment doubles

Are foreign investments taxed?

SA's World Cup boon balloons

WEF: 'Africa can't eat democracy'

 

Johannesburg - South Africa is not attracting enough foreign investment to tackle high unemployment and poverty, the World Bank said on Thursday, citing high labour costs as a key deterrent.

"South Africa is attracting far less foreign direct investment and exporting less industrial output than many countries in the same peer group," a report said.

The investment climate report compared the country with other emerging economies such as Brazil, India and China.

High labour costs and low manufacturing productivity were holding back to the economy, it said, in a country where unions demand salary hikes more than double the rate of inflation.

"The growth of manufactured exports is constrained by relatively high labour costs, including benefits and wages paid to employees," said the report.

South African labour costs outstrip similar emerging markets like Brazil, Chile and Argentina, it said.

Employees of the state-owned logistics and transport company Transnet were earlier this year given an 11% wage hike after a lengthy strike. In June, inflation was at 4.2%.

Government employees are also preparing for a potentially bruising strike next month over salary increases.

While South Africa ranks highly in ease of doing business, unemployment and poverty remain widespread.

"We understand the need for structural changes in the economy to address constraints," Trade Minister Rob Davies said at the release of the report.

"Even during the time of economic boom, unemployment was around 22%, now it is at 25%," Davies said.

Earlier this month, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development urged the government to lower the obstinately high unemployment rate.

  - AFP

  • page

 

Comment on this story

(No bad language or hate speech, please)
All comments are moderated before displaying on the site
Fikile Aug 03 2010 22:12
What a load of cr@p, again an exsample of neo-liberal capitalist onesided reporting @Bouty is correct if the exec were not paying themselves large bonuses and getting double digit % increases then labour would not be making such demands
 
Just look Jul 30 2010 13:19
Just go anywhere in SA (P&Pay, Checkers (etc.). 1 Person working, 5 others doing nothing. What is the cost?? In Germany 2 people run a medium seized ALDI.
 
JP Jul 30 2010 11:59
A real example of labor costs damaging investment. As a textile business owner I've been unable to pay minimum wage to my workers, as the business remains at breakeven level as I compete with cheap imports. Bargaining Council threatens to close me down - knowingly it will make hundreds jobless - for failing to pay minimum wage. Of course I could pay minimum wage, and run a loss-making business and eventually close down. Or oblige with bargaining council, and take my investment elsewhere. Either way, SA loses.
 
Shrek Jul 30 2010 11:38
Thats why most investors are bypassing SA for more investor friendly places like Brazil, India & China. With their productivity levels, work ethic, etc, investors will get more value for their money than in SA. Expect unemployment to increase further.
 
Brandon Jul 30 2010 11:22
The root cause is the FIAT monetary system the world subscribes to. The Central Bank and FIAT money system is designed to put humans and their governments into servitude of an elite group. Religio, Racism and Class are all tools used by this group to keep the worker in servitude and slavery. You people are all trying to fix an unfixable, and whinging into the wind!
 
MC Jul 30 2010 10:51
We are sitting in a vicious circle where those who have jobs want more money. Paying more means that the business case for automation is so much easier to justify, thus less employment on the one hand and on the other hand business holds out until they are completely desperate before they employ. I also believe that EE contributes to low productivity as half competent EE candidates demand higher wages and the others are kept on the books to play the government’s numbers game. Stop trying to socially engineer the economy and focus on education and training. Unfairly advantage the previously disadvantaged in this regard and the Black Empowerment will happen by itself. If this was done in 1994 employment and Black Empowerment would have been much further advanced. Get real, fix the fundamentals.
 
Michael Jul 30 2010 09:32
No country which has protective economic policy can progress. Even the China is the "World Factory", so what? Thier people live better than what they were during its closed door policy period. You can have your BEEE and other policies looked good to the people, but they are not investors who can create job opportunities for the people. Forget about the stikes, no one owe us a living. People having jobs will lear new skill and will be inspired to improve their lives. No job, no future. People will become demoralised.
 
SAGE Jul 30 2010 09:12
HAHAHAHAHA...talk about stating the obvious.SA economy will just have to wait for a miracle thats all. In spite of how bad the situation is the status quo is going nowhere.
 
Fatcats Jul 30 2010 08:24
Fatcats pay themselves ridiculously high monies for being politically connected and useless on the job. No wonder workers want more for themselves.
 
honky Jul 30 2010 08:17
Employment = Marriage in SA. Why on earth would someone wish to get married to countless people they hardly like, apart from paying them vast sums of money !!
 
Pieter Jul 30 2010 08:17
At least the world bank are clever enough to spot this. If we say the same thing we get marked as being racist, I am glad somebody from outside eventually say what we've been saying for 10 years. I wonder how much damage have the unions done in the past 16 years and how many job losses are due to the unions
 
!!!Nad!!! Jul 30 2010 08:00
All you people complaining about double inflation wage increases havent tried living on a salary of 1500 when rates, water, electricity - basic essentials increase by over 20%. Where as the more fortunate are able to absorb this cost and whinge, the majority will literally have to eat less. I do however take exception to these employers (both private and public) that cry there is no money for increses when meanwhile they are taking huge bonuses and 20-30% increases on their already multimillion contracts. yes you have to pay for good leadership skills, but fair is fair i say.
 
AJ Jul 30 2010 06:17
Keeping your voter base is more important than keeping the country competitive, which unsurprisingly ends up actually hurting the voter base more as unemployment bites.
 
RCB Jul 30 2010 05:58
While the fat cats are earning what they do working for the same boss I cant blame the guys at the bottom for striking. The bosses of our larger corporations are getting paid to loose millions and the public is only now getting wind of how much they earn. You cant justify the R1 mil a year salary while you are retrenching the R42k workers and not expect them to strike for their piece of the pie. Dont get me wrong I dont believe in communism but rich or poor in SA. We have to stop printing the money for a few. The gap between the office workers and the floor where the money is actually made needs to be bridged a bit.
 
Ian Jul 29 2010 23:09
You can take this as old news but the reality of the situation will never go away, SA has become so non-productive in terms of cost vs. skills that we now face a severe crisis. Forget about BBBee and AA, get the economy going and running by keeping the current skills and hopefully training more. Stick to your AA and BBBee issues and you will effectively take the SA economy out of contention as far as investors are concerned. For the ethnic dudes who can't deal with the current spread of management and power in SA, being white, I suggest you make a choice: Enjoy your Merc or BMW under the current conditions or force us out and you'll be right back to that donkey-cart in no time, make your choice. Simple.
 
Pat Jul 29 2010 22:46
Rubbish!!! Where are the other factors, like cost of living. The cost of living in SA is significantly higher in SA than in the BRIC nations that we are being compared to! Also, do not believe the WB, they are just feuling class war in many countries. Their recommendations brought countries like Argentina to its knees. Fact of the matter, globalization is a load of hogwash!!! Localize economies and manufacturing so that we do not have to listen to thees fatheads!!!
 
L Jul 29 2010 22:06
I agree with the fact that most top end earners are paid way to much, on the other hand the problem is not so much the fact that transport, food etc is too high, but the majority of African men spend their entire income on booze and the family has to try and survive on the women's meager income... enough said
 
Geejay Jul 29 2010 21:47
do we really want to create the slave shops of China, where companies like Apple pay their employees so little and treat them like robots to the extent that suicide is the order of the day by workers who feel hopeless? Why doesnt the world bank set the example and pay all its fat cats 9 UK pounds a week, maybe we'll see more bankers commiting suicide, now that would be a welcomed event
 
JW Jul 29 2010 20:00
Same story, just from a different source. Anyone listening? Probably not
 
Tree Rat Jul 29 2010 17:55
The problem here is that in order to create jobs, SA manufacturing is labour intensive, but it still has to compete with other countries that are using machinary and automation. Automation is cheaper and more precise. If labour becomes too expensive and unreliable, international clients will simply go where they can get cheaper products. Also, the World Bank doesn't care about AA, BBBEE and EO, so if this is causing inefficiency and high labour costs, then SA needs to address it as well.
 
Markham Adams Jul 29 2010 17:52
Now there's real insightment for you. Africa's Labour costs is to High. Can the World Bank please tell me given that South Africa, Poor/Rich ratio being the highest how somebody being paid a "Hell of a Lot of Money" or should I say, Thousands of poeple, that they could come up with the comment like that. But then again, why am I surprised, after all they're just the messengers of the World's Best Capitalist (read Extortionists) of other poeple's wealth.
 
Ross Jul 29 2010 17:48
Show me the fool that intends to start a labour intensive manufacturing business over here. Remember: Employ today and toy, toy tomorrow.
 
Pavlovs Dog Jul 29 2010 17:29
Does the book "Animal Farm" Ring a Bell?
 
ex employer Jul 29 2010 17:00
@amazed. I wholeheartedly agree with you. I closed my small business for exactly the reasons you state-- high wages, low productivity and lousy work ethic. Dont forget shrinkage as well!! That is totally endemic in this country. It is a soul destroying situation. The unions are doing to this country what the unions did in the UK in the 70s. They had to wait for Maggie Thatcher to stand up to them-- I think we have a long wait ahead of us!
 
expat in UK Jul 29 2010 17:00
This its total nonsence. The average cost to company for the little man in any job back home is still not a fraction of the cost to company for companies in the UK. The Problem is the big shots who demand Big HUGE salaries, with ludicrous golden handshakes if they mess up. SAA's former director case in point. If the so called Investors insisted that the Salaries be more evenly distributed, more realistically, maybe the difference between the bread line and the manure line wouldnt be so disgustingly large. Contrary to the phrase from the movie "Wall Street".. Greed is not good.
 
solo Jul 29 2010 16:58
The problem is not so much labour rates! It's the price of food, transport, education, electricity etc etc. You cant blame workers for wanting higher wages! Bring down the cost of living!
 
Roger Jul 29 2010 16:54
I don’t think that the salary is the real problem, it is our real lack of productivity that makes us uncompetitive! The devaluation of the currency that has been spoken of in recent times is also not a solution to this problem. The entire nation needs to become more productive from the top management to the lowest paid workers only then will you begin to address the international competiveness!
 
Confused Jul 29 2010 16:51
This report says SA labour costs are too high. Other reports you read about say Homeowners are not renovating their houses or Too many South Aficans with bad debts or Too many people can't afford to buy houses. What happened to our money? Do we spend them all on food and clothes and tax and water and electricity? Because I certainly don't have that much sitting in my bank account.
 
Realist Jul 29 2010 16:51
Deos anyone think that this lot will hear the message. They would rather devaluve the Rand and borrow.
 
Nasdaq7 Jul 29 2010 16:51
This leader of COSATU Vavi, isn't he something special? He still believes everyone should work for the government. No one should be wealthy - we should all be miserable and poor. No innovation. No ambition. Those that start their own businesses are fools. Those they try to invent, that try to produce a better product - for export are all fools. Idiots for not allowing the majestic government to take care of them. Remove him - he is a communist - and we can move forward with privatization and a more efficient, small government where people can take the initiate to take control of their lives: start up their own businesses, become producers instead of consumers and wealthy - for once.
 
JC Jul 29 2010 16:48
"High labour costs and low manufacturing productivity". Surprise! I suppose the World Bank will now be branded as a racist, western, anti-revolutionary institution, trying to destroy the glorious peoples revolution for self-enrichment. Try explain this one away ...
 
GinaS Jul 29 2010 16:48
The Unions only ask for higher wages so that their fees may be increased, they are unconcerned about job creation in this country. The labour that we do have unemployed are those that will not reach the hights of president, so the government should be able to creat jobs within its self for these people. The country requires cleaners, gardeners etc. We require the rag trade to be reopened. The private sector will not employ because of Labour Laws that are far to strict. Companies especially the small business should be able to have flexitime workers, if a worker starts to slack in his work and take advantage of having ajob then he should be replaced by someone who wants to work without having the CCMA on your back in other word contract worker should be allowed all the time not only for specific jobs. The contract worker knows that if he does not work well he will be unemployed again. This is a big problem in SA people know that there are benefits for them from the cradle to the grave so they will not make any effort to work well at their jobs, and the Unions are always there to cheer them on.
 
Nick Jul 29 2010 16:45
I could've told them that, it's not rocket science.
 
T Jul 29 2010 16:43
when you compare the cost of living and the wages the cost of living in sa is very high , they should stop comparing sa with other countries as their goverments maybe better than sa in terms of grants and other staff and business is sa to much profit driven that why you will see food retailers earnings all higer the food prices in are very high
 
expat Jul 29 2010 16:42
so what do you make of this minister Mdladlana? dont think EE / AA is going tp help SA get more productive
 
Juan Jul 29 2010 16:38
"High labour costs and low manufacturing productivity were holding back to the economy" In simple terms it means "people are lazy and want big paychecks." I dont need an 'economist' to tell me that. duh
 
Labourer Jul 29 2010 16:37
Well all I can say what is happening in this country, is that the rich getting richer & the poor getting poorer. This is why we see alot of strikes popping up.Also the Top Bras getting fat bonuses & steep increments way above inflation even if they not performing.
 
DeonL Jul 29 2010 16:36
It is better to take a salary cut than to sit at home earning nothing, no wonder "foreigners" take these jobs that local South Africans do not want, when will they learn?
 
Open Minded Jul 29 2010 16:36
What a plonker! I lived in the Middle East for years and years. Trust me, there are ways and means to get anything you want over the internet. Spend this money on health, housing, education and everything else this country so desperately needs!
 
Amazed Jul 29 2010 16:34
Why are you amazed!!Unions have a stranglehold on our economy as well as Government!The Private sector is reeling as the individual employer stands no chance of growth against formidible labour costs and the poor work ethic of the labour force.More and more small business enterprises are going to the wall-due to labour wage demands!Unemployment rates will continue to rise!Tax burdens on small business are not enticing the growth in this area,hence,no further employment opportunities will be made available.Watch this space!!
 
Doped Jul 29 2010 16:33
This is not rocket science at all. Do you think that Govt ministers and Vavi will take notice? They are only in it for personal gain. Why do you think our food prices are so high. There are food chains with too many employee perks and really don't know what to do about it and expect the consumer to keep paying. Many companies went this route and is now catching up, incl a car assembly plant, Govt and parastatals as well. We are heading for economic and social disaster.
 
Investor Jul 29 2010 16:31
How many times from how many sources must the ANC hear this same story before they sit up and listen. COSATU is costing the country growth and jobs. They are part of government, that situation is insane - government is supposed to create jobs and growth yet their alliance partner is destroying jobs and growth. ANC bad economic policy is also to blame. They need to listen up and hire some good economists to derive growth economic policies that make sense.
 
EE Jul 29 2010 16:31
Maybe the unproductive BEE is making SA seem expensive. 5 guys for 1 job.
 
Bouty Jul 29 2010 16:29
If the executive management of SOEs were not paid huge bonuses and Ministers stopped squandering the tax payers’ money labour unions would not be demanding so much wage/salary increases.
 
 
Your name *
Email *
Comment *
 

Please enter the text in the image below as is into the given textbox:

Captcha image
*
 
 

Disclaimer

Fin24.com encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of users published on Fin24.com are therefore their own and do not represent the views of Fin24.com. All posts are monitored by Fin24.com's editors and grossly derogatory posts will be deleted. The Fin24.com editorial team will delete your comment should you post abusive comments, use vulgar language or make discriminatory observations.

Indicators

Last updated: Thu 23:40

View data hub

Company Snapshot

Make money from art
Sep 02 2010 12:48

Art's nicer to look at than stock and bond certificates, but can it make you money? Fin24.com spoke to the experts about this alternative investment class. Time: 3:00

Compare and Buy

Compare and apply for hundreds of financial products from many suppliers.

Credit cards Medical aid Current accounts Think Money

Money Clinic

Money Clinic Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Loading...