See More

India sours for foreign investors

Apr 17 2012 08:18 AFP

Related Articles

India replaces China as Iran’s top oil buyer

India urges airlines to ignore EU scheme

Taking on Big Pharma

India’s top Iranian oil buyer to cut imports

Global businesses warn India over tax plan

Brics vulnerable to global risks - survey


New Delhi - Business consultant Adrian Mutton says it takes courage for a foreign corporation to make a big-ticket investment in India given the uncertainties thrown up by capricious twists in government policy.

Companies have long griped about India's byzantine rules and suffocating bureaucracy but recent policy flip-flops have further soured the investor mood.

"You have got to be a pretty brave CEO to gamble on a major investment decision in India especially if you think that decision may be overturned," says Mutton, who heads India-based Sannam S4, a consultancy which helps firms enter India.

The latest, and for many investors most egregious government measure, was announced in last month's budget which included provisions allowing India to tax foreign takeovers retroactively to 1962.

The plan seeks to override an Indian Supreme Court judgement in January that rejected a $2.2bn tax bill slapped on British phone giant Vodafone over its 2007 purchase of a local operator.

"The Indian government is perhaps hoping the country's economic growth potential will retain companies like Vodafone," Deepak Lalwani, chief of India-focused investment consultancy Lalcap, said.

"But fresh capital will be fearful of the business and investment climate and will be hesitant to come," Lalwani said, cautioning that poor investor sentiment "may dramatically slow future foreign capital".

Already, gross foreign direct investment in India has fallen by a quarter to $20.3bn in the fiscal year ended March, down from $27.1bn in the previous year, according to official figures.

In a letter to Premier Manmohan Singh earlier this month, seven global business groups, including the Confederation of British Industry and the US Business Roundtable, warned of a "widespread reconsideration of the costs and benefits of investing in India."

The investment slowdown comes as India urgently needs foreign funds to upgrade its dilapidated airports, roads, ports and other infrastructure in order to ease bottlenecks and spur growth.

Economic expansion for the last fiscal year is estimated at just 6.9%, the second slowest rate in a decade.

The retroactive change to India's tax code was only the latest piece of news to dismay foreign investors, already preoccupied by policy paralysis on reforms to liberalise the economy and corruption.

The investment plans of Norwegian telecom giant Telenor and other foreign firms who had jumped into the world's second-largest mobile market were left in tatters earlier this year when the Supreme Court cancelled their licences.

The court's move stemmed from a scandal in which the government had issued mobile licences in 2008 at throw-away prices, costing the public treasury up to $39bn, in what is believed to be India's biggest graft case.

The licence cancellation "was a shock for the foreign operators, especially as this was a ruling on a government policy decision," Kamlesh Bhatia, India research director at global consultancy Gartner, said.

And last December, in a major U-turn, the government reversed a decision to allow foreign supermarkets into India after a key ruling coalition ally said the move could hurt millions of small shopkeepers in the country.

"The reform process has really just fallen apart," Manjeet Kripalani, head of Gateway House: Indian Council on Global Relations, told AFP.

Further discouragement has come from a slew of stalled projects, including South Korean steelmaker POSCO's plans to build a $12bn steel mill - first announced in 2005 and trumpeted as India's biggest foreign investment deal.

Late last month, an Indian tribunal suspended environmental clearance for the plant, keeping the project in limbo.

Still, says Mutton of Sannam S4, many global companies have little choice but to enter the increasingly affluent country of 1.2 billion people if they want to boost revenues in light of the slowdown in developed economies.

"You can't afford not to be in India as a marketplace when you look at the huge population," says Mutton, whose India advisory business has tripled in size in the past few years.

"In boardrooms around the world, people are saying if we are going to deliver growth, where do we go? India inevitably comes up. They may know it will be a pain in the backside - but they have to make the best of the situation."

india  |  foreign investment


Read Fin24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Company Snapshot

We're talking about:


Johannesburg has been selected to host the Global Entrepreneurship Congress in 2017. "[The congress] will ensure that small business development remains firmly on the national agenda and the radar screen of all stakeholders, the Small Business Development minister said.

This is the most expensive burger in the world!

You won't believe how much someone was prepared to pay for this burger!


Luxury living

Exclusive food items that WILL break the bank
Top 10 most expensive homes in the world
You can permanently live on a ship and sail the world!
These are the richest people on the planet!

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

How will you manage Vodacom’s price hike for contracts?

Previous results · Suggest a vote