Register now for Fin24 Dashboard and get access to portfolios, watchlists, financial comparison tools, and a whole lot more to help you achieve your financial goals.

Data provided by McGregor BFA
All data is delayed
Loading...
Where am I? Home
 
Prices are delayed by 15min.
Join the Fin24.com conversation about JSE-listed stock by using every time you tweet.

Experts warn against tax for NHI

Jan 27 2011 18:28 I-Net Bridge

Related Articles

Beware dramatic effect of NHI: expert

Sharp decline in doctors expected

NHI to cost less than feared: Treasury

Shisana: NHI tax deductions to start soon

No escape from NHI cost

'NHI plan needs economy to grow 7%'

 

Top Stories

Cell C move sparks price war

May 27 2012 11:21

There's a price war raging between South Africa's cellphone networks after Cell C lowered the rates of its prepaid calls by more than 34%.

Tupperware agents incensed by fakes

May 27 2012 11:49

The country's 200 000-odd Tupperware agents are angry about the counterfeit products being sold as the real McCoy.

Another golf estate victim

May 27 2012 13:09

The oversupply of golf estates has claimed another victim.

 
Share Share line Print

Johannesburg - The elephant in the room on budget day next month will be national health insurance (NHI), said Ernst & Young's tax advisers on Thursday.

They said that while the impact on future expenditure around national health remains uncertain, it would not be good if this became "just another tax".

"We must be careful where the funding comes from," said general tax director Rob Stretch.

Stretch said South Africans are already feeling the heat from additional taxes like import duties. He noted, for example, that cars in SA cost 30% more than those in the UK.

The recent carbon emissions tax also adds to the burden - despite SA's quality of fuel being so poor that not many fuel-efficient engines can be used.

A problem is that the money goes into one pot of funds and is not earmarked for a specific area, such as fixing potholes and traffic lights.

Stretch also said there has been an inefficient use of tax incentives - like enhanced write-off incentives for greenfield and brownfield development, yet to come into operation.

The incentive programme started in 2009, but the regulatory body for approving applications is not set up yet. The touted international headquarter company regime is also facing headwinds, as exchange control legislation around it has not yet been implemented.

VAT director Charl Niemand and Dave Clegg, national tax technical director, do not expect VAT to be increased.

"It can be a can of worms," said Niemand, referring to some moves around the world to separate additional taxes from a single VAT rate. "It is exceptionally unlikely," said Clegg.

He said different rates will be impossible to manage, as was found in the past when the same thing was discussed around sales tax.

Mark Goulding, PAYE and expatriate tax director, expects social security and pensions reform to take a back seat this time due to all the other issues that need resolving.

He also believes that the NHI will not feature too prominently as a task team is still busy investigating and their report will be needed before any major announcements can be made.

Clegg said another problem that could plague the Treasury is the threat of inflation to the government's plans, in the light of oil price increases and the rand depreciating.

He is also not convinced that money can simply be thrown at the unemployment problem without first reforming rigid labour laws.

He says if attempts are made to "lean against the wind" to try to rein in the exchange rate, government must be careful that it does not "get blown over".

 

 

 
 
Comment on this story
27 comments
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining
Facebook's intrinsic value
May 23 2012 11:32

When it comes to judging a company’s worth, value investors like Warren Buffett look at intrinsic value. By that measure, Facebook’s shares are worth less than $10. A Reuters analyst breaks down the math. (Reuters)

Perfin

I arranged two workshops in Cape Town at the Cape Chamber of Commerce offices as well as two computer based workshops, one on Google Adwords and another on Joomla Administrator at the training centre in Somerset West. Emarketing Workshops - http://emarketingworkshops.co.za/next-workshops 1. Interne... Read their blog...

Recently updated
Podcasts
The Sishen saga

Legal expert Peter Leon on the increasingly complex legal wrangle over the Sishen Iron Ore mine. Time: 8:17 Listen Here...

Before you list

Is the clarion call of the JSE calling? Listen to Fin24’s expert panel discussion before you list your small business. Time: 17:29

Compare and Buy

Compare and apply for hundreds of financial products from many suppliers.

Credit cards Medical aid Current accounts Think Money

Money Clinic

Money Clinic Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Loading...