• Clueless leaders

    Zim's leaders are clueless about managing the economy or leading the nation, says Malcom Sharara.

  • Govt is out of touch

    Journalists seems to know more than those paid to govern us, says Mandi Smallhorne.

  • Terry Bell's Inside Labour

    Private firms can't be blamed for picking up anything lucrative on offer, says Terry Bell.

All data is delayed
See More

Alcohol ad ban will cost jobs - study

Jul 05 2011 12:13

Related Articles

Cosatu: Jobless trends bleak


Cape Town - A complete ban on alcohol advertising will result in a total loss of revenue - including sponsorship, sports development leveraging, events and below the line activities - of R2.6bn, a preliminary impact study has found.

The actual impact on alcohol abuse would be negligible, independent marketing analyst Chris Moerdyk said on Tuesday.

Loss of above the line advertising revenue for the mass media would be R1.8bn.

The SABC would lose about R400m, DStv and e.tv combined about R500m, and radio, lifestyle magazines and newspapers the balance.

Another impact on the mass media industry would be job losses of about 2 500 - mainly low-earning employees in the print and out of home (outdoor) sectors, as well as sports marketing and management companies.

However, many media companies believed the figure of 2 500 was too low, Moerdyk said.

The impact on the alcohol industry itself would be a short-term drop in branded liquor consumption of between 5% and 8%, but this would recover in the medium term due to direct marketing.

"Brand leaders would, in fact, benefit from an advertising ban by increasing market share at the expense of lesser placed brands."

The impact on dependants of retrenched employees would result in approximately 30 000 people losing their breadwinners due to the high number of dependants per breadwinner in the lower ranks of the workforce, in particularly the print and out of home industries.

Bans lifted

Precedents in Canada, Denmark, and New Zealand found no evidence of reducing alcohol abuse - which resulted in bans on alcohol advertising being lifted.

The impact on substance abuse in poorer areas would also be negligible due to alcohol and substance abuse emanating mainly from non-branded liquor products such as home brews and methylated spirits as well as glue, tik, and other substances.

Regarding the impact on the South African fiscus, Moerdyk said a study was still under way by an independent accountancy firm.

However, one example would be the loss of VAT on about R2bn of the R2.6bn, due to advertising budgets being allocated directly to the bottom line in most liquor firms. VAT loss would be some R280m.

An unintended consequence of a ban on alcohol advertising would be increasing pressure from within South Africa and the World Health Organisation (WHO) to ban fast food advertising.

The WHO has identified obesity as the biggest global health hazard.

It would be difficult for the government to justify banning alcohol advertising without banning fast food advertising, the impact of which would be a further 3 000 job losses in the media and marketing industries.

The impact on television programming would be twofold. Firstly, the inability to purchase sports programming from overseas due to a loss of revenue, and secondly, the inability to broadcast sports and lifestyle programming containing embedded liquor sponsorship or branded content.

"Given the role advertising leveraging plays in liquor industry-sponsored sports development projects, these projects would more than likely be curtailed or abandoned should the liquor industry not be able to derive any added value benefit."

Further, liquor industry sponsored Drink/Drive advertising campaigns at Easter and Christmas could be severely compromised should liquor industry sponsors not be able to "brand" these campaigns.

South Africa's potential to host international sporting and commercial events and exhibitions would also be compromised should any of these events have global liquor sponsor, such as Budweiser for the 2010 Soccer World Cup, Moerdyk said.

job creation  |  advertising  |  alcohol


Read Fin24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Company Snapshot

We're talking about:


Debt is one of the biggest financial issues facing South Africans today. Find out how you can avoid and manage your debt with Fin24 and Debt Rescue.

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

Labour’s call for a cap on salary of high earners is?

Previous results · Suggest a vote