Johannesburg - Walmart's acquisition of Massmart Holdings
[JSE:MSM] can have a "potentially devastating" effect on local jobs,
three government departments said on Tuesday.
The transaction should be sent back to the Competition
Tribunal for proper consideration and more effective conditions to be imposed,
the departments of agriculture, forestry and fisheries; economic development;
and trade and industry said in a statement.
The three departments filed their heads of argument on
Wednesday in the Walmart Massmart merger case.
"Government has argued that the merging parties will
increase imports, relying on Walmart's vast and extensive international
procurement capability," said Economic Development Minister Ebrahim Patel.
"We are concerned that tens of thousands of jobs could
be lost in the local factories that currently supply Massmart and other local
"We have intervened in the proceedings as government to
support local jobs and industrial capacity in South Africa," said Patel.
The minister of economic development was bound by the law
and the constitution to intervene in the proceedings to ensure realisation of
the objectives of the Competition Act.
Trade and Industry Minister Rob Davies said there was no
evidence that Massmart would create 15 000 jobs because of the merger, as it had
"The tribunal failed to take into account the enormity
of the likely impact of the proposed merger on the South African economy.
"It will result in the closure of many SMMEs (small, micro and
medium enterprises) and firms owned by historically disadvantaged individuals.
The country's manufacturing base could be further eroded and that capability,
once lost, would take many years to win back," said Davies.
Agriculture Minister Tina Joemat-Pettersson said the
implications of a displacement of local suppliers by Massmart would result in
lost income and most likely the loss of jobs.
It appeared that in some industries this had already taken
place since the merger, she said.
"Olive farmers in some parts of the country have been
advised that they should no longer expect orders from Makro (a subsidiary of
Massmart) for locally produced olive oil, as they intend to import cheaper
"If unchecked the shift to imports is likely to have a
catastrophic effect on local farmers and agro-processing manufacturers,"
The three departments said government had asked the court to
send the matter back to the Competition Tribunal for a more considered
evaluation based on adequate information from the merger parties with a view to
much stronger conditions being imposed.
The review and appeal was expected to be heard in the
Competition Appeal Court on October 20 and 21.