• Clueless leaders

    Zim's leaders are clueless about managing the economy or leading the nation, says Malcom Sharara.

  • Govt is out of touch

    Journalists seems to know more than those paid to govern us, says Mandi Smallhorne.

  • Terry Bell's Inside Labour

    Private firms can't be blamed for picking up anything lucrative on offer, says Terry Bell.

All data is delayed
See More

Tobacco giant to fight packaging laws

Jun 27 2011 10:51

Sydney - Global tobacco giant Philip Morris will launch legal action over Australia's plan to introduce plain cigarette packaging, it said on Monday, warning the damages bill could run to billions of dollars.

Under proposed government legislation aimed at reducing smoking rates, due to take effect next year, all logos would be removed from cigarette packaging in Australia, with company brand names printed in a specific font.

Packets would also be a bland olive-green and contain graphic health warnings such as black, diseased gums, blinded eyes and children in hospital.

The proposal, which is being closely watched by other countries considering similar policies, has enraged the tobacco giants, who say it would reduce their profits and see counterfeit products flood the market.

Hong Kong-based Philip Morris Asia (PMA), which distributes brands such as Marlboro in Australia, will argue that Canberra is breaching a bilateral investment treaty between the two countries.

"The forced removal of trade marks and other valuable intellectual property is a clear violation of the terms of the bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong," PMA spokesperson Anne Edwards said in a statement.

"We believe we have a very strong legal case and will be seeking significant financial compensation for the damage to our business."

The notice of claim, which was served on Monday, starts a three-month negotiation period and if no resolution is reached the matter will proceed to arbitration.

"Legal action is not a course we take lightly, but the government has unfortunately left us with no other option," added Edwards.

The Philip Morris statement cited Georgetown University's Don Wallace Jr., chairman of the Washington-based International Law Institute and an expert on investor-state disputes, as saying compensation could be significant.

"Plain packaging legislation would expose Australia to well-founded claims under the treaty, potentially costing the Australian government billions of dollars in damages," said Wallace.

Canberra says 15 000 Australians die of smoking-related diseases every year, and that tobacco use costs the country Aus$31.5bn annually in healthcare and lost productivity.

Though Australia would be the first country in the world to mandate plain packaging, New Zealand, Canada and Britain have considered a similar approach, and Prime Minister Julia Gillard said the government would not be swayed.

"We're not going to be intimidated by big tobacco's tactics, whether they're political tactics, whether they're public affairs kind of tactics out in the community or whether they're legal tactics," she said.

"We're not taking a backward step. We've made the right decision and we'll see it through."

Health Minister Nicola Roxon added that the government was confident it was on "very strong legal ground".

"Tobacco is unlike any other legal product in the world. We know so much about the harm it causes," she told state broadcaster ABC.

"So in those unusual circumstances, taking steps as we have already done in Australia to severely restrict advertising, has not been able to be challenged.

"Similarly, we think this next sensible, logical step will not be successfully challenged either."

Professor Donald Rothwell, from the Australian National University's College of Law, said Philip Morris must first prove a dispute exists.

"A crucial legal issue at this stage is whether there exists a 'dispute' for the purposes of the (bilateral) agreement as no federal legislation has yet been enacted," he said.

"Accordingly, no damage has been suffered by the tobacco companies."

cigarettes  |  smoking



Read Fin24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Company Snapshot

We're talking about:


Debt is one of the biggest financial issues facing South Africans today. Find out how you can avoid and manage your debt with Fin24 and Debt Rescue.

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

Labour’s call for a cap on salary of high earners is?

Previous results · Suggest a vote