• BEE winners and losers

    Creating real change and real jobs requires a new ideology, says Gerhard Papenfus.

  • Governance matters

    Addressing risk well and timeously can be a source of growth, says Ian Mann.

  • Road to riches

    Taxpayers keep funding structures with big plans but who knows what efficacy, says Mandi Smallhorne.

See More

Knott-Craig gets emotional in court

Aug 07 2013 14:40
Alan Knott-Craig

Alan Knott-Craig poses with his book 'Second is Nothing'. (File: Duncan Alfreds, News24)

Company Data


Last traded 207
Change 0
% Change 0
Cumulative volume 2540723
Market cap 0

Last Updated: 31-03-2015 at 03:04. Prices are delayed by 15 minutes. Source: McGregor BFA


Last traded 132
Change 0
% Change 0
Cumulative volume 428225
Market cap 0

Last Updated: 31-03-2015 at 03:04. Prices are delayed by 15 minutes. Source: McGregor BFA

Related Articles

Former boss testifies in Vodacom case

Vodacom's revenue increases

Vodacom mum after settling DRC dispute

Vodacom, MTN 'desperate' for spectrum

MTN, Vodacom after Neotel

Vodacom fails to stop Please Call Me case


Johannesburg - Former Vodacom [JSE:VOD] CEO Alan Knott-Craig was accused of being evasive on Wednesday, when asked if MTN [JSE:MTN] planned to sue the company for stealing the Please Call Me idea.

"Your worship, the witness is being evasive about it," Cedric Puckrin, for former Vodacom employee Nkosana Makete, said in the South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg.

Knott-Craig responded: "I am not trying to be evasive, I am trying to answer as honestly as possible."

Makete took cellphone service provider Vodacom to court to get compensation for the Please Call Me service, which he claims he invented in 2000.

He said his boss at the time, Philip Geissler, promised in an oral agreement to facilitate remuneration negotiations with the company.

Geissler submitted the idea and said he would negotiate remuneration between Makete and Vodacom once it was developed and its technical and commercial feasibility had been ascertained.

On Wednesday, Puckrin questioned Knott-Craig about an email Geissler sent to Makete on March 8 2001, saying MTN was suing Vodacom for stealing the Please Call Me concept.

Puckrin asked if he was aware of the alleged legal action.

'I do not remember'

Knott-Craig responded: "I do not remember them [MTN] accusing Makate. I believe that they did not formally sue Vodacom for stealing their idea.

"I am not sure what happened between Geissler and MTN... What I can tell you, ultimately, we were not sued by MTN. But someone could've called with a verbal threat."

Puckrin said Makete wanted a share of the revenue generated from the idea.

Knott-Craig said Vodacom never had a profit-share or revenue-share agreement with employees who introduced new ideas.

He said he was not sure of the agreement Geissler made with Makete, and said profit-share would be "beyond anything that would be accepted" by Vodacom.

"This particular promise of sharing revenue within a company is not normal. I would've been surprised that he [Makete] believed that a company would share its revenue on an untested product," he said.

"To lead Makete to believe that [the reward he wanted] is beyond what the company could ever give."

He said a bigger bonus and a progression of rank would have been considered remuneration in terms of policy.

"No one has ever suggested revenue-share to me," Knott-Craig testified.


"We do not make additional payments to people... Makete wanted payment for doing nothing other than having an idea for a moment in his life."

Puckrin read various paragraphs from Knott-Craig's biography, "Second is Nothing", illustrating his sense of business, how he made decisions, and that his word was his bond.

Knott-Craig became visibly emotional, looking down and away after the paragraphs were read. He had to clear his throat before speaking again.

Puckrin put it to him: "The culture you instilled in Vodacom in this sense was that you regarded your word as your bond - this is promulgated throughout."

Discussing the delegation of authority, Knott-Craig said he did not need to authorise an agreement with the board or shareholders if the payment was within the budget.

The delegation of authority determined who had the power to sign agreements at the company.

Makete first approached the high court in 2008, after he sent letters to Vodacom in 2007.

The matter was adjourned.

mtn  |  vodacom  |  please call me


Read Fin24’s Comments Policy

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
Add your comment
Comment 0 characters remaining

Company Snapshot

We're talking about:


Johannesburg has been selected to host the Global Entrepreneurship Congress in 2017. "[The congress] will ensure that small business development remains firmly on the national agenda and the radar screen of all stakeholders, the Small Business Development minister said.

Money Clinic

Money Clinic
Do you have a question about your finances? We'll get an expert opinion.
Click here...

Voting Booth

How will you manage Vodacom’s price hike for contracts?

Previous results · Suggest a vote