Share

What Shoprite, Pick n Pay & Spar get right – Tesco doesn’t

Ted Black recently published a piece on British supermarket giant Tesco’s fall from grace and possible revival. The group posted a record annual loss last year. And while earnings in the first quarter of this year did improve, Black noted that all the trend lines pointed South West when looking at ‘Stockspin’ and ‘Return on Assets Managed. In his latest piece, he applies the notion of ‘Stockspin’ to whom he calls the ‘Big Three’ listed on the JSE Food Sector. His research shows that last year Pick n Pay, Spar and Shoprite all made economic profits – cash profit after tax less the cost of equity – a tough measure to beat. – Stuart Lowman

By *Ted Black

A short while ago we looked at Tesco and asked what other companies in South Africa – not just retailers – might have in common.

Sticking with them for now, here’s a Scatter Chart of the big three in the JSE’s Food sector – Pick n Pay, Spar and Shoprite. It shows their “Stockspin” (Sales ÷ Inventory) and Return on Assets Managed (ROAM) compared to Tesco since 2006.

Apart from Tesco’s slight uptick last year when making its huge loss (-13% ROAM), all the arrowed trend lines point South West towards lower Stock turn and lower ROAM.

Given the growth they achieved in terms of Sales, profit and assets over the last ten years or so, you might well conclude that managing gets tougher and tougher the bigger you get… and it does.

On the other hand, showing numbers this way can also reveal a big opportunity. As firms grow, and complexity mounts, we can lose sight of the few numbers that matter most. They are the ones to use to educate people, clarify the critical tasks that have to be done and measured if you want to tap into the hidden potential to improve that exists in all organisations.

Pick n Pay’s performance is particularly interesting. Not that long ago it was #1 in profitability. Yet, despite the problems and decline of the last few years, if you were to levy a charge of 20% on equity, management has still made an economic profit every year. It’s Cash Profit after tax less the cost of equity. A tough measure but they beat it, as did Shoprite and Spar. That’s no mean achievement.

Another interesting issue is that PnP started a SAP ERP implementation in 2005. Why didn’t stockspin improve… or at least stay at similar levels?

It fell from 18.6 in 2004 to 14.4 in 2015. In other words, last year for every Rand of inventory, management generated R14.40 in sales – a drop of almost 23% from R18.60. Despite a new distribution centre coupled to state of the art technology and IT systems, there seems no evidence of a positive impact on asset productivity (Sales ÷ Assets). Maybe it would have been worse without the investment, but who knows?

Some years ago I was at a GIBS seminar to discuss ERP productivity effects, an expert ended the fruitless proceedings by saying, “You just have to trust us, the productivity will follow.” It doesn’t seem to… ask any operating manager at the frontline for views on that.

Maybe it’s because the financial and IT functions use the systems to answer the wrong questions. Instead of “How can we get the right controls in?” maybe a better question is, “How can we help operating guys pinpoint opportunities for lifting productivity…get inventory turning faster for instance?”

The last issue concerns suppliers. Managers who don’t understand what asset productivity means tend to focus on only one side of the ROAM equation – “For every Rand of Sales how many cents profit do we make?” In particular they look at cost and driving down suppliers’ selling prices. This focus can lead to destructive conflict – especially when the retailer then looks for any way to delay payment – which they often seem to do.

Managers also think supplier credit, like equity, is “free” money. It isn’t. It comes at a big “hidden” cost – like slowing “stockspin” – if the relationship is not a collaborative and constructive one.

For insights on this, do a Google search on Tesco and its supplier relationships. There’s a message in there for all businesses. As genuine entrepreneurs know, the first people to put you out of business aren’t banks. It’s suppliers.

Constructive, collaborative relationships with them are vital if you want stock to spin. Toyota started working on that issue many years ago. The sales productivity of assets (ATO – Asset Turnover) is the #1 measure in the ROAM equation and the one that’s least focused on by most operating managers.

Here’s a chart of the “Big Three” and their overall ATO and ROAM performance.

Is it time to think about giving the asset wheels a “spin” and head North East… like Woolies did a few years ago?

We’ll take a look at that next.

* Ted Black runs workshops, and coaches and mentors using the ROAM model to pinpoint opportunities for measurable, bottom-line, team-driven projects. He is also a freelance writer with several books published. Contact him at tblack@astrovoice.co.za

* For more in-depth business news, visit biznews.com or simply sign up for the daily newsletter.


We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Join News24 today
heading
description
username
Show Comments ()
Rand - Dollar
19.04
-0.7%
Rand - Pound
23.98
-0.4%
Rand - Euro
20.53
-0.3%
Rand - Aus dollar
12.36
-0.1%
Rand - Yen
0.13
-0.7%
Platinum
894.10
-0.3%
Palladium
996.00
-0.6%
Gold
2,194.02
-0.0%
Silver
24.42
-0.9%
Brent Crude
86.09
-0.2%
Top 40
67,905
+0.3%
All Share
74,106
+0.3%
Resource 10
56,200
+1.0%
Industrial 25
103,604
+0.3%
Financial 15
16,488
-0.2%
All JSE data delayed by at least 15 minutes Iress logo
Company Snapshot
Editorial feedback and complaints

Contact the public editor with feedback for our journalists, complaints, queries or suggestions about articles on News24.

LEARN MORE
Government tenders

Find public sector tender opportunities in South Africa here.

Government tenders
This portal provides access to information on all tenders made by all public sector organisations in all spheres of government.
Browse tenders